Twelve years ago, as I was transitioning from McKinsey to Axiom, my real dream was to be a writer, and so I decided to write. Other than the children’s books I did with Katy (The Pig and the Hound Series), my first attempt was a novel that I imagined was going to be Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying meets Styron’s Lie Down in Darkness.
The characters were vivid in my mind, the narrative arc was etched, and the plot twists were envisioned with clarity. Armed with everything I believed I needed, I embarked on my writing journey each day in my makeshift home office. After relentless days and nights of creating and refining, I finally had a draft that I was confident about. Excitedly, I shared it with friends for feedback before making my move towards acquiring an agent or publisher.
One of my friends, also a writer, was the first to respond. Their feedback began with an endorsement of my writing capabilities but then, unexpectedly, descended into a blunt assertion that my novel, Separation, was not the piece of work I should pursue.
“[T]here is absolutely no doubt in my mind that you can write a good novel, and that you will if you so choose,” the email began.
Then the other shoe dropped.
“There is also no doubt in my mind that Separation is not that novel - nor will it, or should it, ever be…I really do think the best thing to do would be for you to start over from scratch and modify your approach.”
The revelation was a crushing blow, but I didn't let it deter me. Instead, I took it as a steppingstone and decided to craft a different novel, which, like the previous one, remains unpublished even today.
Nevertheless, I persisted in my writing endeavors. From contributing to friends’ blogs, posting on LinkedIn, to earning a regular spot with Forbes, to guest pieces on Inc.com and HuffingtonPost my work as a writer continued.
A decade later, I found myself with an agent, a publisher, and a book that made its way to The Wall Street Journal bestseller list. To my surprise and delight, the same friend who had steered me away from my first novel, now wrote:
Hey Andrew,
I just finished reading your book and I really enjoyed it. I was so impressed by how well-written it was - clear, concise, etc. Including worksheets at the end of each chapter was a great idea and really helped me engage with the ideas along the way.
Very well done!
This heartening moment filled me with a profound sense of gratitude. I could have interpreted the initial criticism as a discouraging hindrance, but instead, I used it as an incentive to improve. I chose to seek the value within the criticism rather than dismiss it. It became a testament to my potential and an impetus to continue striving towards it.
This brings me to my point in sharing all of this – consistency. This piece marks my 52nd post for this blog, an article published every single week for an entire year. Just like my commitment to write a blog every week, it was not merely the desire to write but the consistency in doing so that propelled me forward.
Often, when people express their ambition to be a “writer”, “actor”, “athlete”, they're imagining the lifestyle they think is associated with these labels. They overlook that there isn't a singular lifestyle applicable to a profession, e.g., I doubt Martin Amis’s days looked much like those of Margaret Atwood. Regardless, none of these are about the lifestyle, but rather it is the dedication to the process and the consistent effort that defines an individual's professional identity. It’s what they do.
Look, I am no Marcel Proust when it comes to writing, I know that. I also know that if I continue to consistently work at it, I can be a better writer next year than I am this year, and a much better writer ten years from now. This isn’t necessarily to chase nice messages from my readers (though those do feel amazing if I am being honest). Rather, it is because I have stories, ideas, and feelings I feel I must get out and share with the world because they can be of benefit to others, and at present this is my medium for doing so. The more I do it, the more consistently I do it, the better I will hopefully become, and the greater the impact I can have.
So, on this one-year anniversary of the blog, a big thank you to YOU for joining me on this journey as I work to consistently get better for your sake, and for mine.