In today’s world, “authenticity” has become a buzzword. We’re encouraged to “be ourselves” and “live our truth.” And while that sounds great, sometimes “authenticity” is just an excuse to be, well, a bit of a jerk. Throughout my career, I’ve seen people excuse abrasive behavior with phrases like, “I’m just a straight shooter,” or “That’s just who I am.” What they’re essentially saying is, “I’m authentically rude, and I’m not interested in changing.”
While honesty is important, we have to remember that being “honest” or “real” shouldn’t come at the expense of kindness. As Taylor Swift famously pointed out, we shouldn’t be “casually cruel in the name of being honest.” There’s a difference between true authenticity and using authenticity as a way to avoid the tough work of self-improvement. If we’re serious about being our true selves, then we owe it to others—and ourselves—to examine the impact of our words and actions. Are we trying to help, or just to let off steam?
The Thin Line Between Being Authentic and Being Rude
Authenticity, when done right, is a great quality. It means expressing ourselves honestly, openly, and without pretense. But authenticity can be twisted into a shield that protects us from self-reflection. When we say things like 'That’s just how I am,' we close ourselves off from seeing how we might be hurting others and hold ourselves back from becoming a better version of who we could be.
Being an “authentic person” doesn’t mean being abrasive, insensitive, or unfiltered. When people dismiss concerns about their behavior by saying they’re “just being real,” they often avoid looking at how that behavior might affect others. Authenticity shouldn’t be about letting ourselves off the hook for acting thoughtlessly.
To Help or to Vent?
When it comes to honesty, we should all take a moment to think about why we’re saying what we’re saying. Are we being honest to inspire change? Are we trying to help someone or provide insight? Or are we just releasing our own frustrations, perhaps at someone else’s expense?
I’ve found that a lot of “honesty” people dole out is less about helping others and more about venting. This isn’t a criticism; we all do it from time to time. But when we use “honesty” as an outlet for our own frustration, it rarely has the effect we’re hoping for. People tend to get defensive when they feel attacked or belittled, even if the intention was simply “telling it like it is.”
Before speaking, it’s worth asking: Is what I’m about to say constructive? Has it ever helped create the outcome I wanted? Or does it usually lead to hurt feelings, defensiveness, or misunderstandings? At its core, true honesty is meant to build bridges, not burn them. And yes, that may take some finesse and tact. But if the goal is to be both authentic and helpful, it’s worth the extra effort.
When “Being Real” Isn’t Enough
Being authentic is important, but so is self-awareness. People are not static; we all have areas where we can grow and improve. Self-awareness means being open to change, especially if we notice that our “authentic self” is creating tension or negative outcomes in our relationships.
It’s helpful to remember that being kind and being true to ourselves are not opposites—they’re actually very compatible. When we consider how our “straight talk” might impact someone else, we’re not compromising authenticity; we’re aligning it with a purpose. Being more thoughtful doesn’t mean we’re less honest; it means we’re more effective in delivering our truth. Think of it as evolving your authenticity to be a little gentler and a lot more intentional.
Honey, Not Vinegar
There’s an old saying: “You catch more flies with honey than vinegar.” Yes, it’s a cliché, but like a lot of things our moms taught us, it also happens to be true. Being straightforward and honest doesn’t have to mean being harsh or confrontational. Thoughtful honesty can be both clear and kind, fostering stronger relationships and making it more likely that people will listen.
The trick is to focus on constructive feedback—keep your words centered on the behavior or issue rather than the person. Show empathy. Ask yourself, “If someone were saying this to me, how would I want to hear it?” These small changes don’t dilute the truth; they just make it more palatable and productive. This approach allows us to maintain our values and integrity while also making a positive impact on others.
This approach is nothing new. Stoics like Marcus Aurelius and Epictetus practiced virtues that balanced truth with compassion, valuing honesty while recognizing the importance of empathy and respect in every interaction. If a Roman Emperor could prioritize this, surely we can too.
Practical Tips for Practicing Self-Aware Authenticity
Here are a few ways to practice honest, authentic self-expression while remaining open to growth:
A Tool for Connection, Not a Weapon
Being true to ourselves is important, but we also have a responsibility to consider how our words and actions impact others. Authenticity isn’t about refusing to change; it’s about being honest enough with ourselves to acknowledge areas for improvement. When we balance honesty with kindness, we become the best version of ourselves—not just for our own benefit but for the benefit of those around us.
So, go ahead—be authentic. Be honest. But let your authenticity reflect growth, kindness, and a genuine intention to connect. That’s the kind of “authentic self” that truly inspires and empowers others.