"Nothing is more unfair than to judge of the sentiments of one age by the improved moral perceptions of another." – Denys Arthur Winstanley
We’ve all heard how unfair it is to judge historical figures by modern standards. The same goes for judging our younger selves. The wisdom we gain over time should not be used as a weapon to critique the person we once were. It’s a lesson I’ve had to remind myself of repeatedly, especially when reflecting on the teenage version of me—someone who the current version of myself might not even be close friends with today.
There was a time when I saw that thought as a judgment on my younger self, an indictment of the choices I made and the person I was. But over the years, I’ve come to view it differently. Now, I see it as a testament to my personal development—a sign of just how far I’ve come. The person I am today wouldn’t exist without the mistakes, confusion, and growth of my younger years.
The Importance of Context and Growth
It’s easy to look back on our past with a critical eye. We think, “I should have known better” or “How could I have acted that way?” But the reality is that the younger versions of ourselves didn’t have the life experience, knowledge, or wisdom we now possess. We didn’t have the full context that today’s perspective offers.
In the same way, you can’t have your 40th birthday without first having your 39th. Life is a series of steps, and each age comes with its own set of lessons. Judging your teenage self by the standards of your adult self is as unfair as judging someone from a different time by today’s moral codes.
Each stage of life is essential in its own right, and our mistakes, missteps, and even the naiveté of our youth were part of the learning process. Without those experiences, we wouldn’t have the wisdom we now possess. The person we were then was doing the best they could with the knowledge and circumstances they had at the time.
The Teenage You vs. The Present You
I often reflect on how different my teenage self was from who I am today. I was brash, impulsive, and thought I knew it all. In many ways, the adult me would find the teenage me frustrating, maybe even intolerable. But rather than seeing this as a condemnation of who I was, I now view it as a celebration of growth.
Back then, I was working through the challenges of adolescence with limited tools. I didn’t have the benefit of hindsight or years of experience. If I hadn’t made the mistakes I did, I wouldn’t have learned the lessons that shaped me into the person I am today.
It’s easy to say, “I wouldn’t be friends with my teenage self,” but I now understand that it’s not about rejecting who I was. It’s about acknowledging how far I’ve come. The gap between the teenage version of myself and the present version isn’t a failure on my part—it’s a reflection of personal development.
Empathy for Your Past Self: Why It’s Necessary
One of the most powerful lessons I’ve learned is the importance of showing empathy to my younger self. Just as I wouldn’t judge a friend harshly for mistakes they made when they were younger, I’ve realized I shouldn’t hold myself to today’s standards when reflecting on my past.
The decisions I made, the paths I took, and even the things I regret now all made sense with the limited information I had at the time. My younger self wasn’t foolish or wrong—they were simply learning. And just like we extend understanding to others, we need to show that same compassion to ourselves.
It’s easy to be hard on ourselves when we reflect on our past. But it’s crucial to remember that personal growth takes time. We wouldn’t be who we are today if we hadn’t been who we were back then.
Parenting and Empathy: Lessons From Talulla
This understanding has also shaped how I parent my daughter, Talulla. She’s incredibly wise for her age—so observant, so insightful—that I sometimes forget she’s still a child. I find myself setting expectations that are far beyond what’s fair for an 8-year-old. After all, how many kids want to hear about the hedonic treadmill during a Monday morning drive to school?
But spending time with her friends during lunch duty at school has been eye-opening. When I dive into play with them, I’m reminded of just how young they all are. Yes, they’re wise in many ways, but they’re also complete babies in others. Talulla, for all her maturity, is still learning, still growing, still figuring out how the world works (and so am I to be fair!).
This doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong with her being a kid in some areas while displaying deep wisdom in others. It’s simply part of her development. I’ve realized that just because she impresses me with her insight doesn’t mean I should hold her to an unrealistic standard in all areas.
Striking the Balance: Recognizing Growth Without Judgment
The key to all of this is adaptability. It’s important to recognize the ways we’ve grown and the wisdom we’ve gained, but without using that as a yardstick to harshly judge our past selves. Yes, we’ve learned more, and yes, we might make different decisions today, but that’s the point. Growth is about learning and evolving.
The lesson I’ve learned is that we shouldn’t judge at all. Instead, we should seek to understand—to appreciate the journey we’ve been on and the ways we’ve grown. This shift in perspective has allowed me to stop being so hard on myself and to appreciate how far I’ve come.
It’s taken me a long time to learn this lesson, but it’s been a transformative one. Developing empathy for your younger self is not just an act of kindness—it’s a recognition of the growth and wisdom you’ve gained along the way. Every past version of ourselves contributed to the person we are today, and that’s something worth celebrating.
So, let’s extend that same empathy to ourselves and others. Life is a journey of growth, and we’re all doing the best we can with what we know at the time. Instead of judgment, let’s choose understanding.