“There is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so.” This famous line from Hamlet is one of those Shakespearean quotes that resonate deeply with how we experience the world. It suggests that events themselves are neutral; it's our perception that colors them as positive or negative. This concept isn't just poetic—it's a profound truth that, when understood, can radically transform how we navigate life.
The Philosophy Behind Perception
Throughout history, various philosophies have echoed this sentiment. The Stoics, for instance, were masters of reframing their perceptions to maintain inner peace regardless of external circumstances. Epictetus, one of the most prominent Stoic philosophers, famously said, “Men are disturbed not by things, but by the view which they take of them.” For the Stoics, the key to a tranquil life was not in trying to control external events, which are often unpredictable and uncontrollable, but in controlling how we interpret and respond to those events.
Buddhism offers a similar perspective. The saying “Pain is inevitable, but suffering is optional” encapsulates the idea that while we may not avoid pain or hardship, we can choose whether or not to add layers of suffering through our thoughts. In other words, the events themselves do not cause prolonged suffering—our attachment to negative labels and resistance to what is happening does.
The Tao Te Ching, a fundamental text of Taoism, offers wisdom on this subject as well: “The Tao does not take sides; it gives birth to both good and evil.” This line speaks to the natural balance of life, where good and bad are not intrinsic qualities but rather human-made distinctions. The universe simply is —and our minds, in their attempt to make sense of it all, assign labels that may not serve us well.
These philosophies share a common thread: the idea that our experiences are shaped more by our interpretations than by the events themselves. It’s a powerful reminder that we hold the pen when it comes to writing the story of our lives.
Teaching My Daughter About Perception
I’ve tried to pass this lesson on to my daughter in many different situations. From small disappointments like losing a football match or not winning a raffle, to bigger frustrations like travel plans disrupted by weather or mechanical issues, I’ve often found myself reminding her that these events aren’t inherently good or bad—they just are. The meaning we assign to them is what determines how we feel about them.
One day, we were enjoying a perfect beach day—lots of sun, laughter, and even the unexpected joy of finding $20 buried in the sand. For my daughter, this was quickly becoming one of her best days ever. But then, as we were getting ice cream, I said no to the “just one more” treat she was begging for, and her mood shifted dramatically. Suddenly, this magical day was ruined in her eyes.
In that moment, I explained to her that she had a choice: she could focus on the one thing she didn’t get and let it spoil her day, or she could remember all the wonderful things that had happened up until that point. I told her that she has the power to decide the story she writes about her day. Is it one of disappointment or one of happiness? That choice is hers to make.
Applying the Philosophy to Real-Life Challenges
Recently, our family went through a particularly intense challenge. At times, it felt overwhelming, and I found myself labeling the situation as “bad.” But each day, I reminded myself that there would come a time when I could look back on this experience with gratitude. I knew that one day, I’d be on the other side of this struggle, able to craft a positive narrative around what we had been through.
That day eventually came. I found myself feeling genuinely grateful for the growth and the lessons we had learned as a family. When I expressed this to my daughter, she was taken aback. “But wasn’t that a horrible thing?” she asked. “Shouldn’t you be sad, not grateful?”
I explained that I was living the advice I always give her. What we had been through wasn’t inherently good or bad—it just was. Yes, there were days when I labeled it as bad and felt the weight of that perception. But ultimately, I chose to write a new story, one focused on positivity and gratitude. I didn’t expect this explanation to immediately change her perspective, but I do hope that seeing me struggle with it in real-time will help her understand this approach more deeply as she grows.
The idea that nothing is inherently good or bad, but that we assign those labels ourselves, is a powerful tool for navigating life. It allows us to reclaim control over our emotional responses and to shape our experiences in ways that serve us better. While this mindset isn’t always easy to adopt, it’s one that can lead to greater peace and resilience.
Whether it’s a lost raffle, a disappointing football match, or a significant life challenge, remember that we have the power to choose how we perceive these events. The stories we tell ourselves about our lives are ours to write. By focusing on the positive and reframing the negative, we can create a narrative that uplifts and empowers us, even in the most difficult times.