In 2016, as I watched the Trump/Clinton Presidential debates unfold, I vividly remember the moment when Hillary Clinton confidently proclaimed, "I believe in science." As someone who values scientific inquiry, I couldn't help but feel a surge of agreement and support. After all, what other position could one take when it comes to understanding the world around us?
However, in the years that followed, particularly during the heated culture wars surrounding COVID-19, it became evident that for many the notion of "science" had transformed into a dogma, an article of faith, rather than a rigorous and open-minded approach to discovery. This realization prompted me to explore what I had in mind when I thought of “science” and the importance of maintaining a truly scientific mindset.
According to Oxford Languages, science is "the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation, experimentation, and the testing of theories against the evidence obtained." At its core, science is a process that involves formulating theories, subjecting them to empirical testing, and continuously refining our understanding based on the evidence at hand. It is not about clinging to absolute knowledge but rather about embracing the journey of discovery and striving to approach closer to the truth.
Somewhere along the way, science seems to have adopted a more archaic definition, or rather we as a society have adopted it, equating “science” to "knowledge." As humans, we are susceptible to cognitive biases, including confirmation bias, which reinforces our existing beliefs and prevents us from critically evaluating new information. To truly embody the scientific approach, we must remain vigilant against falling into the trap of dogma and be open to challenging our own assumptions. Science not only can be challenged but must be challenged if it is to remain scientific.
The renowned philosopher, Jiddu Krishnamurti, expressed a profound insight into the nature of scientific discovery. He stated, "Even the poor scientist, if he wants to discover anything, has to put aside his knowledge and conclusions, because they will color any discovery. Sir, to find out, we must die to the things we know."
Krishnamurti's words hold true not only for scientists but for all of us. To make genuine progress and uncover new truths, we must be willing to let go of our preconceived notions and embrace a mindset of openness and curiosity. Like Faulkner, we must be willing to “kill our little darlings.”
In both scientific inquiry and other areas of life, progress requires humility and critical thinking. Just as scientists must be willing to discard old theories when new evidence emerges, we, too, should be open to revisiting our beliefs and accepting that our current understanding might be incomplete or flawed.
Epictetus wisely noted, "We have two ears and one mouth so that we can listen twice as much as we speak." By actively listening to all sides of an argument and engaging in thoughtful discourse, we can broaden our perspectives and cultivate a more nuanced understanding of complex issues.
It is essential to recognize that science should not be reduced to a team sport. Cheering for our "team" without critically evaluating the evidence or dismissing opposing viewpoints hinders progress. Instead, let us strive to transcend the team mentality and approach discussions with intellectual honesty, seeking the truth rather than to “win.”
In today's increasingly polarized world, where ideologies often overshadow the pursuit of knowledge, it is crucial to reclaim the true essence of science: an unwavering commitment to open-mindedness and critical thinking. The mere proclamation of "I believe in science" is not enough; we must actively engage in the scientific process of observation, experimentation, and the testing of theories against evidence.
Science is not a fixed body of knowledge but a dynamic and evolving pursuit of truth.
To embody a scientific mindset, we must guard against the pitfalls of dogma and confirmation bias. We should be mindful of the biases that can cloud our judgment and be willing to challenge our own assumptions. Krishnamurti's wisdom reminds us that discovery requires us to set aside our preconceived notions and venture into the unknown with humility and curiosity.
Just as scientists discard outdated theories when confronted with new evidence, we too should be open to revisiting and refining our beliefs. By actively listening, valuing different perspectives, and engaging in respectful discourse, we can expand our understanding and develop a more comprehensive view of complex issues.
It is essential to transcend the team mentality that permeates our society. Rather, let us embrace intellectual honesty and seek the truth, even when, and especially if it challenges our established beliefs. Only through this approach can we foster meaningful and constructive dialogue that leads to advancements in knowledge and understanding.
As we navigate the intricate landscape of today's world, we must reclaim the spirit of true scientific inquiry. Science is not a rigid doctrine; it is a process that encourages us to question, explore, and evolve. By embracing open-mindedness, cultivating critical thinking, and avoiding the trappings of dogma, we can foster a society that embraces evidence-based reasoning and the pursuit of truth.
Let us remember that the scientific approach extends far beyond laboratories and academia—it is a mindset that empowers us all to seek a deeper understanding of our world and ourselves.